Pete Peterson: How John Carter Made Me Young Again

Other Stuff

I’m very sorry I missed this when it first came out on March 19.  I spotted it today when someone posted a link to it on Facebook, saying that this had been the review that convinced them to give John Carter a try.   It’s a personalized account of how the author reacted to the movie on a first viewing, then eventually decided to see it again — and how the additional viewing gave him additional perspective and appreciation.   He chronicles his journey with the film very well.  The writer is Pete Peterson, who is the author of The Fiddler’s Gun and Fiddler’s Green.  His bio says he is also “a maker of stinky cheeses, wooden boats, and tasty sandwiches.”  His site, The Rabbit Room, is well worth a visit.

How John Carter Made Me Young Again

by Pete Peterson

When I walked into the theater on March 9th, I was a skeptic. I’d seen some really weird looking previews that I filed into the “what the heck was that” drawer and tried to forget about, until a friend pointed me to a few facts that the trailer failed to mention. First, the movie was directed by Oscar-winner Andrew Stanton of Wall-E and Finding Nemo. Second, the script was co-written by Pulitzer Prize and Hugo Award-winner Michael Chabon of The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Clay and The Yiddish Policeman’s Union. Third, the film is an adaptation of Edgar Rice Burroughs’ Barsoom series which was the direct inspiration for Star Wars,Flash GordonDuneAvatar, and basically every space opera trope of the 20th (and 21st) century.

As weird as it looked, I had to give it a chance.

When I walked out of the theater on March 9th, I was teetering on the verge of conversion. I felt a little like I’d just seen a new Star Wars movie, with a dash of Indiana Jones thrown in, but I was bothered by some perceived second act clunkiness, some thinly written scenes, some general goofiness, and, oddly enough, a nagging suspicion of its “almost-greatness.” My reaction was ambiguous, but I couldn’t shake the film. I couldn’t shake the feeling that for two hours, I’d been a kid again, peering wide-eyed into a fantastic world just beyond the world I could see.

I went home that night and lay in bed, kept awake by visions of four-armed Tharks, warrior/scientist princesses, tall ships that sail on light, and the possibility that somewhere there was a world where I could be more than the broken man I am. I started to wonder if anyone else was feeling the same way. After all, the film hadn’t gotten very good reviews and the media was calling it the biggest flop since Ishtar(ouch).

To my great relief, I discovered I’m not the only one. A quick perusal of Twitter and a few internet haunts quickly revealed that the film was connecting with audiences on a worldwide scale. In fact, it was the biggest movie in the world, despite the fact that it opened with split reviews and a baffling marketing campaign.

Read the full review at The Rabbit Room


  • Just watched it on DVD…man, the film is still a wonderful experience. Just breathtaking, an incredible adventure….the spirit of ERB is all right there in JOHN CARTER.

  • Yeah, I was grinning like a damned fool for days after seeing the movie. It made me write a letter to Stanton thanking him for finally bringing Barsoom to the screen. Only fan letter I have ever written.

  • It comes close to how I feel as well. But I do not consider it to have the issues the writer originally fussed over and what others perceive at all. If we want to go that route, Star Wars had a bunch (including slow spots – which seem slower today than remembered), but most overlook them and just enjoy what was made. I loved this film from the very first moment and every viewing since!

  • Beautifully said….this wonderful movie touches heart and soul…..BARSOOM…

  • This review very much encapsulates my own feelings. No movie is perfect, but few movies are touching the way John Carter is to me.

Leave a Reply